Redlight Poll (Revised)

bill dedman · 03-04-2011, 11:52 PM

You may well be right, Chad. I could agree with that.

But, even if it were true, that would be no reason to condone what we have now, back on the starting line.

What you have suggested is a nebulous, iffy, potential COULD happen scenario, steeped in uncertainty and ambiguity. Possible, yes, but subject to a thousand potential uncertainties. COULD happen, for sure...

But...

This red light rule that we have is an iron-clad certainty, every time.

You bulb first, you're OUT, thus depriving the second car of his chance to do what you just did, and maybe worse.

I think everybody should have his own chance to do that (red light.)

Can't think of any logical, sensible, reason why he shouldn't. Can you?

View Poll Results: Red light poll (Revised)
First car to foul loses	145	64.16%
Worse foul loses	81	35.84%
Voters: 226. You may not vote on this poll

03-04-2011, 11:52 PM	#11
bill dedman VIP Member Join Date: Feb 2002 Location: Conway, AR Posts: 1,739 Likes: 0 Liked 6 Times in 4 Posts	Re: Redlight Poll (Revised) You may well be right, Chad. I could agree with that. But, even if it were true, that would be no reason to condone what we have now, back on the starting line. What you have suggested is a nebulous, iffy, potential COULD happen scenario, steeped in uncertainty and ambiguity. Possible, yes, but subject to a thousand potential uncertainties. COULD happen, for sure... But... This red light rule that we have is an iron-clad certainty, every time. You bulb first, you're OUT, thus depriving the second car of his chance to do what you just did, and maybe worse. I think everybody should have his own chance to do that (red light.) Can't think of any logical, sensible, reason why he shouldn't. Can you? __________________ Bill