CLASS RACER FORUM

CLASS RACER FORUM (https://classracer.com/classforum/index.php)
-   Stock and Super Stock Tech (https://classracer.com/classforum/forumdisplay.php?f=4)
-   -   Wheel Studs (https://classracer.com/classforum/showthread.php?t=70304)

Dan Fahey 06-29-2018 02:10 PM

Wheel Studs
 
Broke a set last year on starting line and missed the Xmas Tree.

Been seeing others lose a wheel from broken Studs.
How often are they replaced?
Is there any special tightening process?
I torque mine to 110 lbs on Aluminum wheels.

Are Moser and ARP the same quality?

D

Mike Pearson 06-29-2018 02:41 PM

Re: Wheel Studs
 
You should not be breaking studs on a car with the HP level that you have. I have never broken a stud on my super stock car even when I was running 1/2 inch studs. Check to see that the back of your wheels are flat and make full contact with the axle face. If the wheels are concave or hollow on the back then you will have problems with the studs. What size studs are you using? I always torqued my 1/2 inch studs to 75 ft lbs. You might be over torqueing yours. I had Moroso studs in my axles.

Lenny5160 06-29-2018 03:18 PM

Re: Wheel Studs
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mike Pearson (Post 566459)
What size studs are you using? I always torqued my 1/2 inch studs to 75 ft lbs. You might be over torquing yours.

Agree. My 1/2 rears get 85 lb/ft, and the 7/16 fronts get 65.

I do 110 or 115 on my dragster with 5/8 studs.

Dan Fahey 06-29-2018 04:28 PM

Re: Wheel Studs
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mike Pearson (Post 566459)
You should not be breaking studs on a car with the HP level that you have. I have never broken a stud on my super stock car even when I was running 1/2 inch studs. Check to see that the back of your wheels are flat and make full contact with the axle face. If the wheels are concave or hollow on the back then you will have problems with the studs. What size studs are you using? I always torqued my 1/2 inch studs to 75 ft lbs. You might be over torqueing yours. I had Moroso studs in my axles.

(Edited)
Using Moser Studs on Moser Axles.
Never had an issue with Breaking Studs before my incident.
Even replaced a pair of Moser Axles.

Our Impala's weigh 4000+ Lbs.
My car on good days cut 1.61 60ft times.

Changed my burn out process.
Once the tires are warm will walk out instead of powering out of the box.

110Lb torque should work for Aluminum wheels

D

Lenny5160 06-29-2018 04:57 PM

Re: Wheel Studs
 
I did buy a complete Moser rear end from a guy recently, and he specifically noted to me the the original Moser studs were junk and he had replaced with ARP.

But I reiterate without knowing your wheel manufacturer that 110 is more than Weld recommends for 1/2" studs.

Larry Hill 06-29-2018 05:11 PM

Re: Wheel Studs
 
Put big studs in and forget about it!

Myron Piatek 06-29-2018 05:14 PM

Re: Wheel Studs
 
Make sure that the lug nut shank isn't too long and bottoming out. Everything I've had has the shank about 1/8" shorter than the wheel center is thick. Gotta be careful with press-in studs that may have a slight "shoulder" sticking out.

Lug nut shank diameters can also vary. It surprised me when doing some searches on Summit's site. A little too small can be just enough to pound the stud to the breaking point.

Make sure the holes in your wheels aren't worn or ovaled.

I've been using 1/2" Moser studs on my CM for 18+ years without breakage. Axles assemblies were changed twice over the years and were still good. Just upgraded to lighter axles. The original axles I had didn't have the Moser decal, but had M/E welded into the register.

MAURICE BLENDHEIM 06-29-2018 06:05 PM

Re: Wheel Studs
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Dan Fahey (Post 566458)
Broke a set last year on starting line and missed the Xmas Tree.

Been seeing others lose a wheel from broken Studs.
How often are they replaced?
Is there any special tightening process?
I torque mine to 110 lbs on Aluminum wheels.

Are Moser and ARP the same quality?

D

Dan… Are you using Wheel Spacers? MB

Dan Fahey 06-29-2018 09:42 PM

Re: Wheel Studs
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by MAURICE BLENDHEIM (Post 566472)
Dan… Are you using Wheel Spacers? MB


No....spacers!.

This year seen a few cars at various drag strips loose wheels.
Bit more than years before.

Moser Studs my car uses are supposedly made from high grade steel.
Figured 110Lb was ok.. was using 85# when they broke.
Some performance wheels are tightened to 110.

I had never broken any in 40 years of racing until last year.
Now more cautious checking the Lug Nuts before each race.

D

John Dinkel 06-30-2018 09:21 AM

Re: Wheel Studs
 
After re installing wheels I re torque after the first run. Usually find a few that need to
be re torqued.

Jim Wahl 06-30-2018 09:46 AM

Re: Wheel Studs
 
Never more than 90# with aluminum wheels! Never less than 75#. 110 is too much stress on the studs. Jim


.

brett3533 06-30-2018 12:37 PM

Re: Wheel Studs
 
I think its possible to over torque wheels that have an inner spacer. After they have been over torqued they begin to rattle when off the car or when being rotated or even rotate where the universal bolt pattern will not align up then if the shank or shoulder does not protrude thru the wheel and the inner spacer has been crushed due to over torqueing when it gets torqued then the nut bottoms out on the shoulder and it may be a little loose allowing it to snap them off ! I like mine torqued at 85ft.lbs for the rear and 65ft.lbs on the fronts also helps keep the rotors from warping from over doing it

Eman 07-01-2018 10:39 PM

Re: Wheel Studs
 
https://www.weldwheels.com/wp-conten...ifications.pdf
https://arpinstructions.com/generaltorque.html
ARP says 125 ft. lbs. Weld says 85-95 ft. lbs.

Coleydog 07-02-2018 08:58 AM

Re: Wheel Studs
 
First you have to find out if they're braking or shearing off. The clamping effect between wheel and axel flange has more to do with the wheel staying on. If it slips, gone. A 6D common nail has about a 2000 lb shear force, I would think the 1/2 stud would be stronger.

Dan Fahey 07-02-2018 10:37 AM

Re: Wheel Studs
 
Thought that Moser Studs were higher quality than Stock Studs.
Hence tightening to 110# for better clamping force.
Plus advice from another racer that did the same.

When the left wheel came off the Studs were supposed to be at 85#.
From Coleydogs post....Breaking or Shearing?
They look like they broke, one had fallen out without me knowing it.
Plus did not check them in a couple months, which I do now often !!!!!!!
So that would indicate they were loose. Correct?

Bought new Studs and Axles from Moser as the Splines were even bent.

Adding one more experience.
After installing the new axles and studs they were Clamped to 85#.
At the track checked them and they were loose and reset them to 85#.

Made a few Q runs and they were loose again.
This time clamped them to 110#.
Checked after the race they were at 110#

This last week pulled all the wheels off and examined the.
Discovered some of the Steel Washers were deformed.
Cleaned the surface of the holes in the wheels and replaced all the Washers and few Lug Nuts.
Never had Steel Washers deform like these did.

Going to contact ARP to learn what Steel Washers they have.
Think I need a better quality.

Are Studs from ARP, Moser and others are made by different Manufacturers?

Dan

Travis Miller 07-02-2018 10:40 AM

Re: Wheel Studs
 
Not that it applies in this case but I'm just saying that over my years of working drag racing I have found that when I've been called to the starting line to look at broken wheel studs, a lot of times there is a wheel spacer involved.

ss3011 07-02-2018 11:54 AM

Re: Wheel Studs
 
Dan , what size wheel studs are you using , are they pressed in or threaded in the axle flange ? It is interesting that you had them loosen up , sounds like something was not seated properly .


I have always used Mark Williams 5/8" drive studs , which has an 11/16" shank which fits snuggly into the lug holes in my Weld Wheels . Never have had a problem with that setup . If you buy new axles , I would recommend switching to that setup .

Dan Fahey 07-02-2018 03:00 PM

Re: Wheel Studs
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ss3011 (Post 566614)
Dan , what size wheel studs are you using , are they pressed in or threaded in the axle flange ? It is interesting that you had them loosen up , sounds like something was not seated properly .


I have always used Mark Williams 5/8" drive studs , which has an 11/16" shank which fits snuggly into the lug holes in my Weld Wheels . Never have had a problem with that setup . If you buy new axles , I would recommend switching to that setup .

Thanks
YEAH agree about the seating.
When the new ones were pressed in they appeared well seated.

At the track checked them with a torque wrench to 85#.
The torque wrenched clicked but did not feel seated the Lug Nut kept moving.

So tightened to 110# where the Lug Nut stopped moving.
Loosened and retightened, it likes 110#.

Dan

D

1320racer 07-02-2018 07:49 PM

Re: Wheel Studs
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Dan Fahey (Post 566467)
(Edited)
Using Moser Studs on Moser Axles.

Our Impala's weigh 4000+ Lbs.
My car on good days cut 1.61 60ft times.



110Lb torque should work for Aluminum wheels

D

https://i.imgur.com/xi93WCy.jpg

3880 lbs. 60 foots 1.30s, best of 1.28. Moser axles and 1/2" studs, torqued to 100 lbs. never broke a stud, thousands of passes and still in service.

FED 387 07-02-2018 11:24 PM

Re: Wheel Studs
 
check your torque wrench better yet use another one to compare to yours ---somethings not right---We tighten/torque our Weld Aluma Star wheels on a Comp Eliminator dragster to 50 pounds check em after every pass never had one loosen up so far

Alan Nyhus 07-03-2018 08:56 AM

Re: Wheel Studs
 
Dan, what rear wheels are you using? -Al

Dan Fahey 07-03-2018 10:13 AM

Re: Wheel Studs
 
1 Attachment(s)
Quote:

Originally Posted by Alan Nyhus (Post 566667)
Dan, what rear wheels are you using? -Al

Centerlines !

Mike Pearson 07-03-2018 10:19 AM

Re: Wheel Studs
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Dan Fahey (Post 566675)
Centerlines !

Take a look at the back side of the wheel where it mates up to the axle flange. The back of the wheel must be perfectly flat where it mates to the axle flange. My buddy had a set of centerline wheels and the backs were not flat. They had a concave area near the stud holes and he could not keep the lug nuts from coming loose and breaking the studs. He finally had to change the wheels and junk the centerlines. After that no problems with the studs breaking or the lugs loosening up.

Dan Fahey 07-03-2018 11:03 AM

Re: Wheel Studs
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mike Pearson (Post 566677)
Take a look at the back side of the wheel where it mates up to the axle flange. The back of the wheel must be perfectly flat where it mates to the axle flange. My buddy had a set of centerline wheels and the backs were not flat. They had a concave area near the stud holes and he could not keep the lug nuts from coming loose and breaking the studs. He finally had to change the wheels and junk the centerlines. After that no problems with the studs breaking or the lugs loosening up.

Thanks Mike;
Did that, took a straight edge and they are flat.

FWIW been drag racing for a long time.
Blew up engines and transmissions.
Stuff happens and hope nobody has the surprise of losing a wheel.

All the advice here is good!
When racing any vehicle got to pay attention to everything.

Looking at ARP again for Studs.
When I freshened the Heads used ARP Head and Header Bolts.

D

FED 387 07-03-2018 11:55 AM

Re: Wheel Studs
 
this may sound stupid but are you using the "correct" lug nuts both either in thread pitch not METRIC on an SAE thread or vice versa as well as the style of nut for that wheel--- IE: cone ,shank etc.?? Weld/Centerline says 85 pounds for most of their wheels with 1/2 inch studs so something is not correct in the application here.Also I would get another torque wrench to tighten them then double check the torque with your wrench see if it clicks at the same rate---FED 387

Chris1529 07-03-2018 11:57 AM

Re: Wheel Studs
 
Do you have the correct lug nuts? If the taper is not right, the lug nut won't seat right.
Do all the lugs loosen up if 85# is used?

Dan Fahey 07-03-2018 12:08 PM

Re: Wheel Studs
 
Here is a good one: LOL ~!

https://www.facebook.com/OldRustyCar...E0MjMzMDQ4NjY/

Dan Fahey 07-03-2018 12:11 PM

Re: Wheel Studs
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris1529 (Post 566685)
Do you have the correct lug nuts? If the taper is not right, the lug nut won't seat right.
Do all the lugs loosen up if 85# is used?


They do now !
In fact replaced all the Washers.
Some were deformed.

The new Studs were tightened until they felt snug and seated.
The rears are now at 110# and fronts back at 85#

FED 387 07-03-2018 12:19 PM

Re: Wheel Studs
 
Now that's funny. Almost looks like it was probably planned

Sean Marconette 07-03-2018 02:02 PM

Re: Wheel Studs
 
I had 4 of the 5 1/2" wheel studs shear on my car in 2007 just after painting it. The problem was the lug nut shank did not engage far enough into the spacer. Even if you are not running spacers, if it is a shouldered lug nut the stud may be allowed to flex and shear. I installed 5/8" screw in wheel studs and never had another problem with wheel studs.

Are you sure the lug nut is not grabbing the wheel and that is the false torque reading? Do the lug nuts drag of hang up when threaded onto the stud with no wheel the full thread length? I also use a dab of anti seize on the wheel studs.

Bobby DiDomenico 07-03-2018 02:08 PM

Re: Wheel Studs
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Larry Hill (Post 566470)
Put big studs in and forget about it!

Problem with that is stock wheels no longer can be mounted.

Dan Fahey 07-03-2018 10:53 PM

Re: Wheel Studs
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Bobby DiDomenico (Post 566693)
Problem with that is stock wheels no longer can be mounted.

Sometimes!
I can still mount my stock SS wheels with the extended Wheel Studs.

As for new studs.
Mine would not stay at 85# after installing them.
Re-Torqued them to 110# until the Torque Wrench indicated they were tight.

Today taking previous advice mounted new M/T Front Runners and Slicks.
Torqued rears to 100# and fronts to #85#.

Larry Hill 07-04-2018 06:31 AM

Re: Wheel Studs
 
My bad, I thought it was a problem on a race car.

Dan Fahey 07-04-2018 10:05 AM

Re: Wheel Studs
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Larry Hill (Post 566719)
My bad, I thought it was a problem on a race car.

You correct! It was the 95 Impala SS.
Just can mount the Stock SS wheels and tires even with Long Studs to store the car over the winter.

Dave Gantz 07-04-2018 11:34 AM

Re: Wheel Studs
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Dan Fahey (Post 566729)
You correct! It was the 95 Impala SS.
Just can mount the Stock SS wheels and tires even with Long Studs to store the car over the winter.

Maybe Larry is talking about bigger diameter studs.

Dan Fahey 07-04-2018 04:27 PM

Re: Wheel Studs
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Dave Gantz (Post 566733)
Maybe Larry is talking about bigger diameter studs.

Yup missed that..
To do that would have to Machine the Wheels for Larger Studs.
Going to a stronger higher strength Stud should be enough!

Ed Wright 07-04-2018 06:35 PM

Re: Wheel Studs
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Dan Fahey (Post 566750)
Yup missed that..
To do that would have to Machine the Wheels for Larger Studs.
Going to a stronger higher strength Stud should be enough!

Which would be the logical thing to do.

Dan Fahey 07-04-2018 09:33 PM

Re: Wheel Studs
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Ed Wright (Post 566754)
Which would be the logical thing to do.

I have Moser Wheel Studs!
That good enough?
D

james schaechter 07-05-2018 05:30 AM

Re: Wheel Studs
 
I really think something is not right with the wheel vs the lug nut perhaps. So what if the shank was too long and bottoming on the stud ever so slightly? The result would be a wheel that was not being clamped as tightly as you think. It could allow the wheel to work on the studs and eventually break them. Maybe this came up before. You could face the shank on the lug nuts to shorten them up a touch if they were close.

Bobby DiDomenico 07-05-2018 06:49 AM

Re: Wheel Studs
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by james schaechter (Post 566767)
I really think something is not right with the wheel vs the lug nut perhaps. So what if the shank was too long and bottoming on the stud ever so slightly? The result would be a wheel that was not being clamped as tightly as you think. It could allow the wheel to work on the studs and eventually break them. Maybe this came up before. You could face the shank on the lug nuts to shorten them up a touch if they were close.

Had to do that with some lugs that bottomed out on the hub and brake drum Jim. Measured the wheel thickness and a shop with a coolant cutting wheel shortened them for me. Big diameter studs were not an option because they would have limited the wheels we could throw on the car.

Seems something here is preventing the wheel from being clamped tight.


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 03:47 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
Copyright © Class Racer.com. All Rights Reserved. Designated trademarks and brands are the property of their respective owners.