CLASS RACER FORUM

CLASS RACER FORUM (https://classracer.com/classforum/index.php)
-   .90 Heads Up Class Racing (https://classracer.com/classforum/forumdisplay.php?f=6)
-   -   Throttle Stop w/ 1 blade TB / roll RPM Q (https://classracer.com/classforum/showthread.php?t=68542)

DailyDriverSst 12-23-2017 01:57 PM

Throttle Stop w/ 1 blade TB / roll RPM Q
 
For the few out there that use Toilet Bowls or LS/Coyote/Holley/FAST EFI, what is the consensus on throttle stops with a single blade? Has anybody gotten it to work consistently?

For short durations (only on stop for ~1/2 sec), how much roll RPM variance becomes noticable in ET?

I'm building a new motor combination right now, should be able to run 10.30-40's based on numbers from similar builds. Would rather use a stop to get off the line, than try to knock timing out of it to get to the 80's.

Lenny5160 12-26-2017 01:26 PM

Re: Throttle Stop w/ 1 blade TB / roll RPM Q
 
I run a Ron's Terminator, which is the same system as the toilet although it does have 4 blades rather than one large one.

With that system, I have the best luck bringing it all the way back to dead idle. I've tried to carry some RPM while on the stop, but it varies too much.

With that said, closing the throttle completely works very well for me.

bottombulb 12-26-2017 03:25 PM

Re: Throttle Stop w/ 1 blade TB / roll RPM Q
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Lenny5160 (Post 552461)
I run a Ron's Terminator, which is the same system as the toilet although it does have 4 blades rather than one large one.

With that system, I have the best luck bringing it all the way back to dead idle. I've tried to carry some RPM while on the stop, but it varies too much.

With that said, closing the throttle completely works very well for me.

That's because it's mechanical fuel injection, nothing to do with the throttle blades.

Lenny5160 12-26-2017 05:07 PM

Re: Throttle Stop w/ 1 blade TB / roll RPM Q
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by bottombulb (Post 552469)
That's because it's mechanical fuel injection, nothing to do with the throttle blades.

I replied with my experience because I don't feel that the number of blades is particularly relevant, but called out the number of blades that I have since he specifically asked about throttle stops with a single blade.

Any injected application with an inline stop should behave similarly, although managing the fuel metering with EFI is surely different from MFI and I have no experience in that arena.

Tom Goldman 12-26-2017 06:11 PM

Re: Throttle Stop w/ 1 blade TB / roll RPM Q
 
The problem you have with a large bore single blade is closing it far enough to get it to actually slow down the air flow enough .
I have closed the throttle of some EFI Stock Elim .cars to where the TPS is at 55 -60% and all that happens is we loose a little 60' but the car actually makes it back up between the 330 and 660 clocks.
Like Lenny said you need to go closed farther , maybe not to idle but I would say at least down to 25-35% open . ... .when you try to slow a small amount of E.T. ,It becomes more difficult to maintain control of the RPM .
I would try going out farther on the first number in the timer , maybe at least past the 60' before going on the stop. that will allow you to run the second timer a little longer.
Also you should be running an open loop , Closed loop will just play hell with the car at part throttle.

DailyDriverSst 12-27-2017 12:52 AM

Re: Throttle Stop w/ 1 blade TB / roll RPM Q
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Tom Goldman (Post 552478)
The problem you have with a large bore single blade is closing it far enough to get it to actually slow down the air flow enough .
I have closed the throttle of some EFI Stock Elim .cars to where the TPS is at 55 -60% and all that happens is we loose a little 60' but the car actually makes it back up between the 330 and 660 clocks.
Like Lenny said you need to go closed farther , maybe not to idle but I would say at least down to 25-35% open .

This is exactly why I asked. I know the issue came up in Pro-Stock, and has also been dealt with on the flying toilet.

This is exactly the info I wanted to know. Yes it will be FOL for index racing, and CL for driving back and forth to the local track and around town (trailered any further). The tuner and platform has proven well in similar builds for bracket racing in various areas, including a track champion up north. But he does not run a stop with his single 68mm blade, and is slower than 6.95 (small displacement OHC NA motor).

With that said:

This will be a very low boost procharged engine with A2A. There are others with a similar combination running at 8-10 pounds and running very close to the SG index in grudge racing. Knowing how centrifugal boost can vary widely with atmospheric conditions, I'm hoping that I can drop down to 4-5 pounds as a baseline, then adjust the stop as per normal use to get to the 10.85-90 window.

The good thing with centrifugal is that I do have a couple options to work with. I know a few T/D guys are using manually/timer activated BOV's to dump at the big end. By nature, centrifugal is only making boost at high RPM. Essentially, I can hang the BOV open on the 2 step and on the stop, and keep the engine completely out of boost until it comes off the stop - unless I do as stated above and hit the timer at the 60'. I feel that this would help with the consistency factor.

It will take some time to learn the curve, but this is more of a fun project than strictly for SST. Goal is to run the 2019 DragWeek street class without the stop, and bracket race and SST with the stop. Trying to make the build be as versatile as possible.

A 4150 is bolt-on, as will a 2 barrel TB, but an elbow and LS/Ford style TB will be much easier to package with the piping.

Tom Goldman 12-27-2017 09:34 PM

Re: Throttle Stop w/ 1 blade TB / roll RPM Q
 
Launching on motor is a smart move . ....You wont have to worry about overpowering the track and will be able to keep a more consistent 60'.
The only thing I would be wary of is spinning the tires down track when the boost comes in .

DailyDriverSst 12-28-2017 06:40 PM

Re: Throttle Stop w/ 1 blade TB / roll RPM Q
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Tom Goldman (Post 552552)
Launching on motor is a smart move . ....You wont have to worry about overpowering the track and will be able to keep a more consistent 60'.
The only thing I would be wary of is spinning the tires down track when the boost comes in .

If I spin downtrack with a 30.0 / 9.0 ( MT 3066 ) tire, I probably will have other problems. Especially if I can keep it down around 4-5-6 psi. Really depends on how aggressively it comes off the stop, and if I do the 1-2 shift on the stop or afterward. Only testing will be able to sort that out.

Tom Goldman 12-28-2017 11:58 PM

Re: Throttle Stop w/ 1 blade TB / roll RPM Q
 
With a small tire like that , shift on the stop . less likely to spin and you will get more MPH
The 3066 is a bias tire so it should handle coming back under power with that low boost.

C5 Pete 12-29-2017 12:00 PM

Re: Throttle Stop w/ 1 blade TB / roll RPM Q
 
Question about the single blade TB.

Are you talking about a cable operated TB with a throttle stop, or using a plate under a DBW TB?

I’m trying to figure out a solution to this same problem as the OP. I’m currently using a DBW TB, but I can make the switch to cable, if it’s the only way to make it work.

Thanks for any guidance.

Lenny5160 12-29-2017 01:04 PM

Re: Throttle Stop w/ 1 blade TB / roll RPM Q
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Tom Goldman (Post 552609)
With a small tire like that , shift on the stop . less likely to spin and you will get more MPH

Not saying that I disagree that he should shift on the stop, but I don't agree that it will result in more MPH.

I'm NA, but in both my S/ST and SC car I come off the stop in Low and shift downtrack on RPM. I lose little to no MPH doing this, and especially in SC I will out-MPH cars that have 200+ more horsepower than I do. It takes a lot of power and time to get the car moving in High gear.

Again, if I had a supercharged small tire car I'd be shifting on the stop, but it will cost you some MPH.

Marc 12-29-2017 01:58 PM

Re: Throttle Stop w/ 1 blade TB / roll RPM Q
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Lenny5160 (Post 552645)
Not saying that I disagree that he should shift on the stop, but I don't agree that it will result in more MPH.

I'm NA, but in both my S/ST and SC car I come off the stop in Low and shift downtrack on RPM. I lose little to no MPH doing this, and especially in SC I will out-MPH cars that have 200+ more horsepower than I do. It takes a lot of power and time to get the car moving in High gear.

Again, if I had a supercharged small tire car I'd be shifting on the stop, but it will cost you some MPH.

I think they way Tom recommends the OPs car will be traveling slower while on the stop therefore shortening stop time and increasing the length of track to gain MPH. Personally I saw a noticeable increase in trap speed and decrease in stop time just by shortening the shift point from .65 to .40.

Lenny5160 12-29-2017 02:41 PM

Re: Throttle Stop w/ 1 blade TB / roll RPM Q
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Marc (Post 552652)
I think they way Tom recommends the OPs car will be traveling slower while on the stop therefore shortening stop time and increasing the length of track to gain MPH. Personally I saw a noticeable increase in trap speed and decrease in stop time just by shortening the shift point from .65 to .40.

Agree that the earlier on the track you go WOT will result in higher MPH, all other things being equal.

Disagree that with stop RPM and stop ON time being equal, a car coming off the stop in High gear will have more MPH than the same car coming off the stop in Low, even with the Low gear setup having a longer stop duration and going WOT further down the track.

DailyDriverSst 12-29-2017 04:35 PM

Re: Throttle Stop w/ 1 blade TB / roll RPM Q
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by C5 Pete (Post 552638)
Question about the single blade TB.

Are you talking about a cable operated TB with a throttle stop, or using a plate under a DBW TB?

I’m trying to figure out a solution to this same problem as the OP. I’m currently using a DBW TB, but I can make the switch to cable, if it’s the only way to make it work.

Thanks for any guidance.

Cable operated TB. FAST/Accufab 4150 (4x44mm) comes with morse ball and F&B 2x58mm can be optioned for a morse ball. Single blade I am still working on, but i'm told that if you can get through to Accufab or Holley tech support, that it's possible to have a morse ball linkage made for their 90-105mm TB's. Worse case, there are 10" cable-wrap to 10-24 morse stud adapters made. But I hate cable-wrap TB's because you can't use a toe hook if it hangs open- it will just push the cable off the guide rather than push the blade closed.

A blade stop will not work with EFI for same reason it won't work with Enderle/Rons injection. You can restrict the airflow all you want, but the barrel valve or ECU TPS will still see WOT and be dumping fuel in.

Just for my 2¢ , I agree (especially in my case of being on the heavy side for factory interior; essentially super stock trim) that coming on the stop in high gear will control wheel speed but lose MPH and possible consistency from the motor lugging from basically a 20-30 MPH roll in high gear. On the other hand, coming off the stop in low gear may yield a traction limited situation depending on how the boost curve comes in.

I'd like to think that even at 9" wide, a 30" tire with a powerglide and 3.89 gear would be pretty damn hard to spin coming off the stop in low gear. But again, depends on the boost curve.

C5 Pete 12-29-2017 10:33 PM

Re: Throttle Stop w/ 1 blade TB / roll RPM Q
 
Thanks for the reply. Like you, I’m looking at how to adapt a rod to the single blade TB. I could use a 4150 and an elbow, but I’d prefer not.

And as for forcing the blade closed if it hangs open, I have an interior battery cutoff that will kill everything mounted to my shifter.

DailyDriverSst 12-29-2017 11:06 PM

Re: Throttle Stop w/ 1 blade TB / roll RPM Q
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by C5 Pete (Post 552688)
Thanks for the reply. Like you, I’m looking at how to adapt a rod to the single blade TB. I could use a 4150 and an elbow, but I’d prefer not.

And as for forcing the blade closed if it hangs open, I have an interior battery cutoff that will kill everything mounted to my shifter.

I would like to see somebody do an A/B test on a known good intake manifold, pulling through a 4150 with nothing on it, then with a hat/elbow on it, then with a 4150 elbow and single blade TB.

These are the adapters i've found.

https://www.kartek.com/parts/push-pu...-body-cam.html

http://www.pacificcustoms.com/cabletb.html

C5 Pete 01-03-2018 12:00 PM

Re: Throttle Stop w/ 1 blade TB / roll RPM Q
 
So, with these adapters, the cable mounts just like a standard cable on throttle body, but the threaded end screws onto the end of the ts shaft?

I was considering welding a rod onto the blade cam of the throttle body to attach the rod, but maybe this cable adapter would work better.

DailyDriverSst 01-07-2018 01:36 PM

Re: Throttle Stop w/ 1 blade TB / roll RPM Q
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by C5 Pete (Post 552984)
So, with these adapters, the cable mounts just like a standard cable on throttle body, but the threaded end screws onto the end of the ts shaft?

I was considering welding a rod onto the blade cam of the throttle body to attach the rod, but maybe this cable adapter would work better.

From my understanding, it has 10" of cable that wraps on the cam like the OEM throttle cable, then has an adapter to screw onto a morse cable or throttle rod.

C5 Pete 01-08-2018 08:32 PM

Re: Throttle Stop w/ 1 blade TB / roll RPM Q
 
Well, I ordered the 10" cable from Kartek.

I have a TS coming from Biondo, and a cable TB to replace my DBW TB.

I will figure out a way to mount this onto the Holley Hi Ram I have on my 427 LSX.

I'll report back once I get everything.

B1Ken 01-12-2018 02:43 PM

Re: Throttle Stop w/ 1 blade TB / roll RPM Q
 
For what it's worth, I used a Ron's Terminator on the stop for ONE RUN. I got gassed out by the Methanol, so I put the carburetor with gasoline back on. I ran the Terminator on the stop with a solenoid bleed actuated by the throttle timer, through a 90 pill at 3500 rpm. Worked fine

DailyDriverSst 01-16-2018 02:06 AM

Re: Throttle Stop w/ 1 blade TB / roll RPM Q
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by B1Ken (Post 553587)
For what it's worth, I used a Ron's Terminator on the stop for ONE RUN. I got gassed out by the Methanol, so I put the carburetor with gasoline back on. I ran the Terminator on the stop with a solenoid bleed actuated by the throttle timer, through a 90 pill at 3500 rpm. Worked fine

The terminator isn't bad on the stop. The Toilet Bowl is what has throttle tip-in and CFM issues with a stop. Info from somebody with that setup would be great


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 04:42 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
Copyright Class Racer.com. All Rights Reserved. Designated trademarks and brands are the property of their respective owners.